Tuesday, September 30, 2008
Weekend Read- Immigration and mixed signals.
These weekend's readings were pretty interesting. I've never really ever noticed it. How although we say that they have to assimilate to our culture, our culture is doing quite the opposite. There are countless ways that we are assimilating to them. Almost inviting them to come in for we will make the transition easy for you. For instance there are countless bilingual classrooms and even bilingual ballots that are offered. Knowing this now has really given me a new perspective on the issue and has made me understand more.
Illegal Immigrants help?
Of course the illegal immigrants do not get all the goodies such as education and health care, and yet they pay their fair share of taxes in sales, property, municipal, payroll and even federal income tax. I have just learned that those unable to find jobs in their own countries just cross the border and come to the US, because work is plentiful and illegal wages are substantially higher than at home. I have heard that America won't run without all those illegal immigrants working in every part of the country. If they weren't illegal, they wouldn't be doing all the dirty jobs that Americans don't want to bother doing.
Monday, September 29, 2008
Just Trying to be American
Immigration has always been a topic that is close to my heart. Since I am from South Texas, I personally knew and had close encounters with illegal immigrants. I personally believe that illegal immigrants are some of the most hard working people in this country, but are never given the chance to actually fulfill their goals; trying to make a good life for themselves and their families.
In the readings it talks about how illegal immigrants take the jobs that americans won't take. I think this is a fair assessment to make.
Additionally, I feel that when illegal immigrants come into our nation they have no idea what they are getting themselves in to. Punishing illegal immigrants will not solve the problem, because they are not the problem. I personally feel that working with central and south American nations (a main source of our illegal population) is one effective step to take.
The readings offered an interesting perspective on immigration.
I specifically agree with the statement, "the worst thing is for a society to set up a new and separate economic class with a different set of rights."
That is the development of America right now. As a country we treat illegal immigrants like third class citizens. Now whether or not this is intentional or on purpose is up to the individual person, but the way we talk, joke, and just portray illegals are always in a negative light.
Immigration
These readings offer a lot of insight to the process of immigration. They explore the hardships and challenges that immigrants, specifically illegal immigrant, must face as they make their way into new nations. Is it really fair to offer them so much sympathy when they are in fact breaking laws? On the other hand, is it fair to deny them a chance to pursue success and a better life?
Immigrants are trying to find a better life for themselves. America, being such a rich country, is an ideal destination for many. In Annan's speech, he promotes the often overlooked benefits of immigration to the American culture and economy. Without the use of immigrant labor, the economy would be very different. These people who are willing to take whatever jobs necessary to earn a living are helping to support our economy.
Annan describes the United States as a "nation built by immigration." Can a nation that was formed by the coming together of different cultures actually hault immigration? While so many American citizens are opposed to legal and illegal immigration alike, would it actually be possible for the economy to continue to flourish if immigration was drastically decreased?
Immigrants are trying to find a better life for themselves. America, being such a rich country, is an ideal destination for many. In Annan's speech, he promotes the often overlooked benefits of immigration to the American culture and economy. Without the use of immigrant labor, the economy would be very different. These people who are willing to take whatever jobs necessary to earn a living are helping to support our economy.
Annan describes the United States as a "nation built by immigration." Can a nation that was formed by the coming together of different cultures actually hault immigration? While so many American citizens are opposed to legal and illegal immigration alike, would it actually be possible for the economy to continue to flourish if immigration was drastically decreased?
response to 9/30 readings
These readings are very sympathetic to illegal immigrants. One of the main points supporting this illegal immigration is that we need these workers to do jobs that we, as Americans, are unwilling to do. But as our unemployment rates rise, will this continue to be true? Also, why is the unemployment rate among illegal aliens historically higher than that of natural born American citizens if these immigrants are filling such a large void in our economy? This argument about these immigrants doing these dirty jobs just doesn't hold water. They do these jobs for lower wages than many Americans would, but I think someone would do them.
These articles also conveniently forget to mention the ridiculously high crime rate among these illegal immigrant populations.
These articles also conveniently forget to mention the ridiculously high crime rate among these illegal immigrant populations.
when workers opt not to go home vs mexican migrant
What was interesting about these two articles from this weekend's readings was that in "Mexican Migrant" the author proposed the idea of enforcing a "properly constructed guest worker program that regulates flow of workers into the country, depending on economic conditions in the United States." She believes that it may not be the best solution but would be a good solution to the growing illegal immigration problem that we have now. As opposed to the "when workers opt not to go home" article, the author indicates that "the worst thing is for a society to set up a new and separate economic class with a different set of rights." Both cases were very similar in terms of the immigration problem but were presented with two solutions that contradicted one another.
Immigration - Weekend Readings
After reading this weekend’s readings, I have mixed feelings about immigration. I am not sure if it is our responsibility to help people assimilate. At times, I feel like we should encourage assimilation, so people can feel welcomed to our country and make a smooth transition. Other times, I feel like many people who immigrate should at least learn the language prior to coming to the country. It might sound harsh, but it must be extremely difficult for people to come to the country who do not know anything about the language. How are you able to get the basic necessities without learning the language? As far as it being the government’s responsibility, I do not think they should have complete control over immigration nor is it their duty to help people assimilate. I feel like people who want to assimilate will and people who do not, well, should not come to a country that they do not want to be a part of. As far as the whole coyote thing, I am not sure how people can be so desperate to leave the country and fall into such a trap. I would rather give up my unhappiness than risk my life. I cannot distinguish if the author was trying to be comical in that section of the book. “Do not trust those who offer to take you to ‘the other side’ and ask you to drive a car or to take or carry a package for them.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)