Monday, September 15, 2008

ch.2

So we start learning some real rhetoric now.
Notice that i used the present tense for the preceding sentence.
Now I've actually got to think what tense I'm going to use before I say something, and it's already giving me a headache. The book has been stressing tenses so much, and it keeps mentioning these common sense people such as Aristotle and Cicero, whom I honestly don't really know too much about, except that they are VIPs; very important philosophers. I have also learned the three tools; blame, values, and choice. Blame is past, values are present, and choice is future. I understand the basic concept, but I have been having a hard time figuring out when and how I can actually apply these rhetoric in real life. Would I have enough time or would I even be able to think of these rules in real situations? It seems like I have already been applying many of these rules unconsciously in my daily life.

I am a little bit surprised that the author says in the book that he assumes that most people out there, if not everyone, doesn't know rhetoric. Is rhetoric something that important? Then why is not everybody learning it?

Outsourcing student voice

In the Chapter titled "Trading Jobs" in Global Issues, Local Arguments, a particular letter caught my attention. A student, Nicole Neumiller, describes how outsourcing has affected where she lives. It never really occured to be that outsourcing really affected a large amount of Americans, but it does. She recalls her aunt telling her about the large amount of layoffs in her Washington community. As more and more work is outsourced to India, more people are being layed off from work. I thought that only the bad jobs were being taken, but after reading this, it seems to not be true. She even mentioned that those who are layed off are unable to find new jobs. This is slightly disturbing. It seems that outsourcing really is more hurtful to our economy then it is helpful. Nicole explains that even though American businesses are benefitting from outsourcing, that many families in the middle class community are being hurt and suffering from a loss of income. After reading this I truly wonder, is outsourcing hurting the economy or helping it?

Thank You for Arguing Ch 2 and 3

I really enjoyed these two chapters of thank you for arguing.
In chapter two I agree with the three types of communicating to your audience. The first part of the three steps is to stimulate your audience, then you change their opinion and finally, get the audience to act. I did speech in high school and this part of the chapter made so much sense. I really feel this will also help translate in the writings as well. 
In chapter three it also made alot of sense in terms of argumentation. With the different types of statements (Blame, Values, & Choice)- I think when we start to write our papers this chapter will really help in the type of thesis that we write. My favorite example was the parents who are arguing on weather or not to pay for braces. IT IS SO FUNNY When the father says- ya a bucktooth graduate. Is this the right type or argumentation? I think it incorporates humor and guilt- it was a good example. 

The best advice given in these chapters was- never debate the undebatable. In order to argue effectively you must be able to settle and issue and communicate your thoughts effectively. 

Good first couple chapters!

"OutSourcing"

Well I think that outsourcing can be a good thing because it is part of globalization, but more people get to experience life in a different culture.But I think its important that we stay in our own nations because we work to hard to get our degrees and continued our education, just to find out that the only jobs that are available our in another nation.This can created social problems in the family.Why is the government not creating jobs in our nations for future engineers and manufacturing jobs? I agree with the theory that the increasing of outsourced jobs will become an economic threat to many American workers. Just think about very few people are not willing to move a way from their families in another country. I do agree that it will cause the unemployment rate to increase.If i had an opportunity to go to another country just for a job I would not take it. I was born in the U.S I believe its the government duty to provides more jobs to keep our economy up for middle-class people.

Thank You for Arguing Ch 2-3

I enjoyed these readings, especially chapter 3. Chapter 2 talked a lot about the structure of an argument. Ive seen that in speech class, but I really like the mood, mind, desire format Heinrichs uses. Now, the tenses in chapter three is something I have never paid much thought. I am going to go back and re-read this chapter a few times. It seems very helpful and is something I am going to have to try on people...

Thoughts on the Outsorcing Bogeyman

I found that The Outsourcing Bogeyman by Daniel W. Drezner was an interesting take on globalization, the first of our assigned readings to enumerate all the good aspects of it. I found it interesting that all of the statistics that he presented showed that although we may have lost American jobs to outsourcing in one area, the financial benefits to that company enable it to create higher paying jobs here. One thing that I find troublesome is the fact that with the right statistics, you can get them to say whatever you want. I felt that some of his stats were simply numbers he was throwing out to help prove his point. For example, he said: “…Although 70,000 computer programmers lost their jobs between 1999 and 2003, more that 115,000 computer software engineers found higher-paying jobs during the same period”. Maybe I’m interpreting this excerpt incorrectly, but to me it’s saying that it’s okay that these computer-programmers lost their jobs because higher paying jobs were created for engineers. The rich get richer so it doesn’t matter that the poor lose their jobs? I don’t see how that’s supposed to even out.
Other than that, I found some of his points enlightening on the other aspects of globalization then those I previously failed to find out more about.

In chapter’s 2 and 3 of Thank You For Arguing, I found it extremely interesting that there are different tenses and techniques of arguing associated with the Three Core Issues associated with arguing.

oh globalization...

On page 25 of Thank You For Arguing Heinrichs talks about the number 3 goal of an argument which is to get an audience to do something or to stop doing something. He refers to the great example of getting young people to vote. And how yes, you may persuade them to a particular candidate, and even better register them as a legal voter, but until REAL challenge is having them show up on election day.
I find it interesting how every issue involving persuasion will fall into one of three categories: blame, values, or choice. Each category also deals with a different tense (past, present and future).

Oh, and I think its obvious that Hernrichs is huge fan of The Simpsons considering a large majority of his examples come from the show's dialog.

It was great to see in The Thirty Little Turtles reading that Indians take pride in helping Americans with their PC's. However, the last time I called the Dell customer service I received little help with my computer because of the language barrier. Not only was it hard to understand the operator, but I felt like he was taking me in circles. Now, I know that is just one example, so I'm being super bias but it was just so frustrating. Although it is good to hear that more women are being employed as call center workers, thus providing them with a decent income and more liberty. This reading had a lot of information to absorb but I did like reading about the advantages to outsourcing and why globalization is not as horrible as it seems.